Answers to the questions experts, solicitors and agencies ask us most often. If your question is not covered here, please email [email protected].
What does Obiter Review do?
Obiter Review reads an expert report that has already been written and returns a separate, advisory review. The review flags matters that may affect the clarity or compliance of the report, such as typographical errors, internal inconsistencies, unclear reasoning and gaps in compliance with CPR Part 35, Practice Direction 35, CrimPR Part 19 and the Criminal Practice Directions. Every decision about what, if anything, to change stays with the author.
Does Obiter Review write or change any part of my report?
No. Obiter Review never amends or rewrites a report, never suggests wording and never offers an opinion. Nothing it produces is inserted into the report. The review is a separate document, and the report remains entirely the expert’s own work.
If I revise my report after a review, has AI shaped my opinion?
A review may prompt you to look again at a passage. It does not supply the answer. If you decide to revise your reasoning, the revision and the reasons for it are yours, and you must be able to explain and defend them in evidence.
A review can influence how a report is finally expressed. That is why we recommend that experts disclose their use of Obiter Review, and keep a record of what was flagged. That record lets the court see exactly how the review was used.
What is deleted, and when?
- Your report is permanently deleted from our systems once the review is complete.
- The review is available to you through a secure, password-protected link for seven days. It is then permanently deleted from our systems.
We keep no copy of either. Deletion applies to our systems only. Once the seven days have passed, the only copy of the review is the one you have saved.
What should I keep?
We recommend that you:
- Save or print the review within the seven days, and keep it on your case file with your drafts.
- Keep the draft you submitted alongside the final report, so that any changes can be identified.
Together, the review and your drafts give a complete record of what was flagged and what changed, held by the person accountable for the opinion.
Why don’t you keep a copy of the review for me?
Because reports contain sensitive information, we hold nothing longer than we need to. The record of how a review was used belongs with the expert, as part of their own case file and under their own record-keeping and data protection obligations, not with a third party.
Should I disclose that I used Obiter Review?
That is a choice for you. Obiter Review may not have identified anything you want to change in your report, although we hope it will highlight relevant areas to review yourself. Not every quality-control use of AI strictly needs to be reported, but our advice is simple: say so – in the spirit of transparency. A short statement in the report removes any room for doubt. For example:
Before finalising this report I used Obiter Review, an independent quality-assurance/ proofreading service, to check it for internal consistency, procedural compliance and drafting errors. Obiter Review did not draft, amend or suggest wording for any part of this report. The opinions expressed are my own. I have kept a copy of the review and a note of the changes I made in response to it. My aim in using Obiter Review was to better fulfil my duties to the court.
Could I be asked to produce the review?
You should assume that you could be. Whether a review is protected from disclosure in any particular case is a legal question, and we do not give legal advice. Keeping the review and your note of the changes means you can produce them, and explain exactly how the review was used, if the court or the parties ask.
Does anyone at Obiter Review read my report?
No. Processing is fully automated, with no human access at any stage. Reports are processed offline in England on hardware owned and used only for Obiter Review. No public, consumer or general-purpose AI platform is used, and nothing is used for training. Full details are in the “Methodology, ethics and security” section of our home page and in our privacy notice.
How much does it cost, and how long does it take?
£25 per report. The review is typically ready in around 10 minutes, and you receive an email when it is ready. No confidential information is ever sent by email.